Doctor Profile

Primary Care · Nurse Practitioner

Natalie S. Macdonald

Nurse Practitioner
5645 LAFAYETTE RD
SUITE B
Indianapolis, IN 46254
✓ Accepts Medicare 🎓 14 Years Practicing
199
Medicare Patients / yr
9
Procedures Billed
14
Years Practicing
4
Hospital Affiliations
Data Source: Identity from NPPES (2026). Procedure & patient volume from CMS Medicare Provider Utilization & Payment Data (2023). Hospital affiliations from CMS Physician Compare. We display publicly reported data — no personal information required to view any of it.
Reviewed by: Wes Ward, Founder & Data Lead • View our methodology

Important: We are not affiliated with Medicare, CMS, or Natalie S. Macdonald's practice. This page displays publicly available CMS data to help you research Medicare providers. We do not sell insurance or represent any insurance company. For official enrollment and complete plan information, visit Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE.

Medicare Plans That Cover Natalie Macdonald

See which plans Natalie Macdonald accepts

We're pulling plan acceptance data directly from insurance carrier provider directories. Until that feed is live for Indiana, the fastest way to find a Medicare plan that covers Natalie Macdonald is to compare every Medicare Advantage and Part D plan available near 46254, IN — the Nurse Practitioner's office can quickly confirm which of the top local plans they accept.

Compare Medicare Plans near 46254, IN →

Or call the office at (317) 387-3050 to confirm acceptance directly.

What Natalie Macdonald Does

Natalie Macdonald served 199 Medicare patients across 266 services in the latest CMS reporting year. That's 31% below the average Nurse Practitioner in Indiana (288 patients across 4,797 doctors).

ProcedureServicesMedicare Patients
Established patient office or other outpatient visit, 30-39 minutes (99214)11567
Established patient office or other outpatient visit, 20-29 minutes (99213)4432
Subsequent nursing facility care with moderate level of medical decision making, per day, if using time, at least 30 minutes (99309)2218
Annual wellness visit, includes a personalized prevention plan of service (pps), subsequent visit (G0439)1818
Urinalysis, manual test (81002)1613

How to read this: "Services" are the total times Natalie Macdonald billed Medicare for each procedure in the latest reporting year. "Patients" counts unique Medicare beneficiaries. Procedures are shown in plain English; the underlying HCPCS codes are available on request.

Hospital Affiliations

Natalie Macdonald is affiliated with 4 hospitals according to CMS Physician Compare. Below are the 4 hospitals with full quality profiles on our site. Hospital network status depends on your Medicare Advantage plan — always verify before enrolling.

Northwestern Medicine Central Dupage Hospital

Winfield, IL
★★★★★ 5/5 CMS Rating

Iu Health West Hospital

Avon, IN
★★★★☆ 4/5 CMS Rating

Ascension St Vincent Hospital

Indianapolis, IN
★★★☆☆ 3/5 CMS Rating

Indiana University Health

Indianapolis, IN
★★☆☆☆ 2/5 CMS Rating

Practice Location & Telehealth Readiness

Natalie Macdonald practices at the address below. If you're evaluating Medicare coverage, location matters for in-network access and — when Natalie Macdonald offers telehealth — broadband availability at your home matters for virtual visits.

Address: 5645 LAFAYETTE RD, SUITE B, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Phone: (317) 387-3050

Area Safety Grade

C+

Block-level crime analysis from CrimeGrade.org.

Practice Accessibility

26 min

Average commute time in this zip · 89% of residents drive to work. Practical context for patients deciding whether to make the trip. See the full neighborhood profile at BestNeighborhood.org.

Telehealth Readiness

77.2876

Households with fiber broadband — important for reliable virtual visits. Check your address at ISPReports.org.

Get directions on Google Maps →

Other Primary Care Doctors near 46254, IN

If Natalie Macdonald isn't accepting new patients or isn't in your plan's network, these are the closest primary care doctors near 46254, IN:

DoctorSpecialtyMedicare Patients / yrDistance
Ashley K. MundilNurse Practitioner110<1 mi
Joseph C. BrinkleyNurse Practitioner752<1 mi
Staci SchroederNurse Practitioner<1 mi
Britney EstherNurse Practitioner<1 mi
Amanda CrowleyNurse Practitioner<1 mi

View all primary care doctors near 46254, IN →

How to Use This Information

Choosing a Medicare plan that covers Natalie Macdonald takes three steps:

Compare Medicare Plans near 46254, IN → All Doctors near 46254, IN

Natalie S. Macdonald: Common Questions

Does Natalie Macdonald accept Medicare?
Yes. Natalie Macdonald is enrolled with Medicare and listed in the CMS Provider Enrollment, Chain, and Ownership System (PECOS). Whether a specific Medicare Advantage plan covers Natalie Macdonald depends on that plan's provider network. Compare Medicare plans near 46254, IN →
Where is Natalie Macdonald's office?
Natalie Macdonald practices at 5645 LAFAYETTE RD, SUITE B, Indianapolis, IN 46254. Phone: (317) 387-3050.
What Medicare plans does Natalie Macdonald accept?
Original Medicare (Parts A & B) is accepted. Medicare Advantage plan acceptance varies by carrier and plan year. Call the office at (317) 387-3050 to confirm your specific plan is accepted, or compare all Medicare plans near 46254, IN to see available options.
Does Natalie Macdonald offer telehealth visits?
CMS does not currently list Natalie Macdonald as offering telehealth. Call the office at (317) 387-3050 to confirm whether virtual visits are available.
How experienced is Natalie Macdonald?
Natalie Macdonald graduated in 2012 and has been practicing for approximately 14 years. In the latest CMS reporting year, Natalie Macdonald treated 199 Medicare patients across 9 distinct procedure types.
How do I know if Natalie Macdonald is in-network for my Medicare plan?
Network status varies by plan. The best verification steps: (1) check your plan's provider directory at the carrier's website, (2) call the office at (317) 387-3050 and ask which plans they currently accept, and (3) call the number on the back of your Medicare card. Print our doctor questions checklist →

About the Reviewer

Wes Ward

Wes Ward

Founder & Data Lead

Wes Ward reviews all doctor profiles and methodology for data accuracy. Every Medicare provider page on this site — including the utilization statistics, hospital affiliations, and geocoded practice address — goes through his data-validation pipeline before publication. We display only publicly available CMS data; you never need to enter personal information to see any of it.

With 25+ years in data analytics — including work with highly regulated genomic data at Ancestry.com — Wes brings enterprise-level rigor to healthcare transparency. He is also a co-founder of BestNeighborhood.org (neighborhood data), CrimeGrade.org (block-level safety analytics), and ISPReports.org (broadband availability for telehealth). Those sister sites power the location and telehealth-readiness context on this page.

View full profile →LinkedIn

Data sources: CMS NPPES (2026), CMS Medicare Provider Utilization & Payment Data (2023), CMS Physician Compare, CrimeGrade.org, BestNeighborhood.org, ISPReports.org. This page is for informational purposes only. Always verify coverage directly with the plan and practice. Read our full methodology →Privacy policy

Medicare Resources

Choosing the right Medicare plan involves more than just doctor coverage. These guides help you evaluate the full picture:

Medicare Plans for Conditions Treated by Primary Care Specialists

See which Medicare plans score highest for conditions commonly managed by this specialty in 46254, IN:

Does your Medicare plan cover Natalie Macdonald?

Compare Plans near 46254, IN →